b1

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Richard Holbrooke, noted diplomat, is dead at 69


Richard Holbrooke, noted diplomat, is dead at 69

By Joe Sterling, CNN
December 14, 2010 -- Updated 0349 GMT (1149 HKT)
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • NEW: President Obama calls Holbrooke a true giant of U.S. foreign policy
  • Secretary Clinton, Sen. Kerry pay tribute to Holbrooke
  • Holbrooke was known as the "chief architect" of the Bosnian accords
  • Holbrooke ruffled feathers in a career that spanned Vietnam to Afghanistan
(CNN) -- Richard C. Holbrooke, the high-octane diplomat who spearheaded the end of the Bosnian war and most recently served as the Obama administration's point man in the volatile Afghan-Pakistani war zone, has died, officials said.
The 69-year-old diplomat died Monday at George Washington University Hospital in Washington. He was admitted last Friday after feeling ill. Doctors performed surgery Saturday to repair a tear in his aorta.
One of the world's most recognizable diplomats, Holbrooke's career spanned from the Vietnam War era to the war against the Taliban and al Qaeda in Afghanistan and Pakistan, coinciding with presidencies of the past five decades from John F. Kennedy to Barack Obama.
He also worked as a journalist and an investment banker. But as a diplomat, he was plain-speaking, accessible, and known for his tough-mindedness.
President Obama called Holbrooke "a true giant of American foreign policy who has made America stronger, safer, and more respected."
Richard Holbrooke dead at 69
Richard Holbrooke: 'A force of nature'
Holbrooke a 'giant of American policy'
Holbrooke's legacy overseas
"Tonight, there are millions of people around the world whose lives have been saved and enriched by his work," Obama said in a statement.
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said the nation had lost "one of its fiercest champions and most dedicated public servants."
"He was the consummate diplomat, able to stare down dictators and stand up for America's interests and values even under the most difficult circumstances," Clinton's statement said, later adding: "Few people have ever left a larger mark on the State Department or our country."
Referring to Holbrooke's notorious intensity, Clinton said that "true to form, Richard was a fighter to the end."
"His doctors marveled at his strength and his willpower, but to his friends, that was just Richard being Richard," Clinton's statement said.
Democratic Sen. John Kerry of Massachusetts, the chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, also cited Holbrooke's reputation for toughness and hard work.
"He was always a man on a mission, the toughest mission, and that mission was waging peace through tough as nails, never quit diplomacy -- and Richard's life's work saved tens of thousands of lives," Kerry said in a statement.
Noting that Holbrooke's first assignment was in Vietnam, Kerry said that "it is almost a bittersweet bookend that a career of public diplomacy that began trying to save a war gone wrong, now ends with a valiant effort to keep another war from going wrong."
In an interview with CNN, Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari called Holbrooke an "extremely hard-working man" who can "get things done which would otherwise take weeks to get through."
"He was known as a bit of a bull in a China shop," said Nic Robertson, CNN's senior international correspondent who knew and covered Holbrooke.
"When he makes deals the crockery tends to get broken," Robertson said.
Holbrooke was best known for being "the chief architect of the 1995 Dayton Peace Agreement" that ended the Bosnian war -- the deadly ethnic conflict in the 1990s that erupted during the breakup of Yugoslavia.
Holbrooke a 'team player'
Wesley Clark: Holbrooke larger than life
Holbrooke wanted to replace Karzai?
Serving President Bill Clinton as assistant secretary of state for Europe from 1994 to 1996, Americans got a taste of Holbrooke's drive and intellect, as typified in this remark from "To End a War" -- his memoir of the Dayton negotiations.
"The negotiations were simultaneously cerebral and physical, abstract and personal, something like a combination of chess and mountain climbing," he wrote.
After President Obama took office in 2008, Holbrooke took one of the toughest diplomatic assignments -- U.S. special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan, the region Obama regards as center of the war on terrorism.
"The environment was different," Robertson said.
Holbrooke's assertive style worked in the Balkans, but it brought perils for diplomats in Afghanistan and Pakistan, where long stretches of chatting and tea-drinking are the norm.
"Once you've insulted someone that's it, your relationship is probably never going to recover," Robertson said.
He was frank in his assessments about the region and officials in both countries regarded him as abrasive, including Afghan President Hamid Karzai. In April of 2009, there were reports of a heated argument between Holbrooke and Karzai after alleged fraud in the Afghan presidential election.
In an October interview with CNN, Holbrooke cautioned patience in the struggle against the militants and for democracy in the so-called AfPak region, a mission that he said was of the "most vital importance to our national security interests."
"We are determined to see it through," he said, and he made reference to the Vietnam War and the Dayton Accords in his insights.
"I'm not in the spin patrol of the people who are giddy with optimism on the op-ed pages of some papers or the people who say it's another Vietnam and it's hopeless," he said. "It's certainly not another Vietnam, for reasons you and I discussed before.
"And it is certainly not hopeless. But anyone who doesn't recognize what a daunting task it is is misleading. And the American public should understand that this is not going to be solved overnight. ... it is going to be a difficult struggle. It has a political component, where you're not trying to win this war militarily, and a Dayton-type negotiation is also very unlikely."
A graduate of Brown University, Holbrooke's experience extended from Vietnam to the post-9/11 era.
He joined the Foreign Service in 1962 and served in Vietnam, a job that included a tour of duty in the Mekong Delta for the Agency for International Development.
In the 1960s, he worked on Vietnam issues at the Lyndon B. Johnson White House, wrote a volume of the Pentagon Papers and had been part of the U.S. delegation to the Paris peace talks over Vietnam.
From 1970 to 1972, he was the Peace Corps director in Morocco and served as managing editor of Foreign Policy from 1972 to 1977.
During the Carter administration, Holbrooke was assistant secretary of state for East Asian and Pacific Affairs and was in charge of U.S. ties with China when that relationship was "normalized in December of 1978," the State Department said.
He later held senior positions at two leading Wall Street firms, Credit Suisse First Boston, where he was vice chairman; and Lehman Brothers, where he was managing director.
Along with his negotiation of the Dayton peace agreement, Holbrooke also served as "special envoy to Bosnia and Kosovo" and special envoy to Cyprus on a pro-bono basis while as a private citizen.
Over the years, he commented on this and other major events in the Balkans with candor.
For example, when former Yugoslav strongman Slobodan Milosevic died in prison in 2006, Holbrooke said, "His actions led to the deaths of over 300,000 people, four wars, the destruction of stability in southeastern Europe, the creation of criminal gangs. Let's talk about the victims of his actions; he was never going to see daylight again, and that was appropriate, and now he's gone."
When Bosnia Serb leader Radovan Karadzic was caught in 2008, Holbrooke hailed it as a "historic day."
"One of the worst men in the world, the Osama bin Laden of Europe, has finally been captured. A major, major thug has been removed from the public scene.
"He was at large because the Yugoslav army was protecting him. But this guy in my view was worse than Milosevic ... he was the intellectual leader," Holbrooke said.
When he visited Bosnia in 2008, the memories of his own family history -- when his Jewish grandfather fled Germany after Hitler took power -- and the ethnic cleansing of Muslims in Bosnia prompted him to reflect.
"I thought I'm seeing a color remake of the black-and-white scenes we'd seen in World War II of Jews signing away their property at the point of a gun and then being shipped off to who knows where," Holbrooke said.
"I don't think you have to be Jewish to understand that what you're seeing was a genuine crime against humanity. The Europeans were doing nothing, and the Americans were doing less," he said.
He worked from 1993 to 1994 as the U.S. ambassador to Germany and served as U.S. ambassador to the United Nations while a member of Clinton's Cabinet from 1999 to 2001.
He was an adviser to candidates, such as the presidential campaign of Sen. John Kerry in 2004.
The Obama administration swiftly appointed Holbrooke to the special representative job and Holbrooke dove in headfirst to tackle the challenges. One of them is the fact that the foes are diffused.
"A peace deal requires agreements, and you don't make agreements with your friends, you make agreements with your enemies," he told Fareed Zakaria in October.
He mentioned a range of militants groups, such as the Afghan Taliban, the Pakistani Taliban, the Haqqani Network, and Lashkar-e Tayyiba and noted that "an expert could add another 30."
"There's no Ho Chi Minh. There's no Slobodan Milosevic. There's no Palestinian Authority. There is a widely dispersed group of -- of people that we roughly call the enemy. There's al Qaeda, with which there's no possibility of any discussion at all."
"There is no clear single address that you go to," Holbrooke said.

Monday, December 13, 2010

Pakistan Floods - Review

Pakistan Floods

    DANIEL BEREHULAK / GETTY IMAGES
    Already beset by wide-spread extremist militancy, saddled with a weak civilian government and in the midst of a considerable fiscal crisis, Pakistan already had more than its fair share of trouble. But monsoon rains in July triggered almost unprecedented flooding that inundated the Indus river basin — at one point, almost a fifth of the country was under water. Around 20 million Pakistanis were displaced by the rising waters; some 2,000 people died as well as an estimated 10 million heads of livestock. The damage to the economy — by some accounts up to $43 billion — has been a withering blow to the Pakistani state, which struggled to come to the aid of many of the stranded and homeless. Reports suggest that charities linked to fundamentalists often filled the void. The international community was also slow in responding to the unfolding calamity — while over $742 million in aid was committed to Haiti within days of its earthquake, a paltry $45 million had been set aside for Pakistan a month after the rains began.

    WikiLeaks Shows the Skills of U.S. Diplomats

    WikiLeaks Shows the Skills of U.S. Diplomats

    A remarkably broad consensus has formed that WikiLeaks' latest data dump is a diplomatic disaster for the U.S. While there are debates over how the Obama Administration should respond, everyone agrees that the revelations have weakened America. But have they? I don't deny for a moment that many of the "wikicables" are intensely embarrassing, but the sum total of the output I have read is actually quite reassuring about the way Washington — or at least the State Department — works.
    First, there is little deception. These leaks have been compared to the Pentagon papers. Which they are not. The Pentagon papers revealed that the U.S. engaged in a systematic campaign to deceive the world and the American people and that its private actions were often the opposite of its stated public policy. The WikiLeaks documents, by contrast, show Washington pursuing privately pretty much the policies it has articulated publicly. Whether on Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan or North Korea, the cables confirm what we know to be U.S. foreign policy. And often this foreign policy is concerned with broader regional security, not narrow American interests. Ambassadors are not caught pushing other countries in order to make deals secretly to strengthen the U.S., but rather to solve festering problems.(See the top 10 leaks.)
    The cables also show an American diplomatic establishment that is pretty good at analysis. The British scholar Timothy Garton Ash concurs, writing in the Guardian, "My personal opinion of the State Department has gone up several notches. [W]hat we find here is often first-rate." It is also often well wrought. The account of a wedding in Dagestan filed by William Burns, now the No. 3 person at the State Department, is — as Garton Ash writes — straight out of Evelyn Waugh. When foreigners encounter U.S. diplomats and listen to their bland recitation of policy, they would do well to keep in mind that behind the facade lie some very clever minds.
    The most significant revelations in the trove are those relating to Arab views of Iran. We now have official confirmation of something many of us have been saying for years: Arab regimes share Israel's concerns about a nuclear-armed Iran. In fact, since they do not have the massive nuclear deterrent that Israel possesses, Saudi Arabia and Egypt are probably even more nervous about an Iranian bomb. It's one thing to have diplomats expressing these sentiments in private, quite another to have the direct and explicit words of the King of Saudi Arabia.(See TIME's exclusive interview with WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange.)
    I understand that these revelations embarrass the Arab regimes, which publicly speak only of the Palestinian cause but privately plot against Iran. But why is that bad for the U.S.? The WikiLeaks data powerfully confirms the central American argument against Iran's programs: that they are a threat to regional stability and order, not merely to Washington's narrow interests. (Israel's Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu quickly pointed this out.) In fact, the simplest confirmation of the fallout can be found in Tehran's reaction to WikiLeaks. Alone among world leaders, Iran's President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad claims that the documents were actually leaked by Washington. After all, they expose as an utter lie Ahmadinejad's constant claim that he has befriended all Arab states and that, if not for Washington, Iran would be beloved by all in the region.(How will WikiLeaks affect the U.S.'s relationship with Germany?)
    If we're looking for bad government policies, perhaps the place to look is not in the cables but in the new data-sharing craze. The leaks are, in some ways, an unintended consequence of Washington's finally getting its information act together. For more than a decade, one often heard complaints that the U.S. government was a dinosaur in the information age. The 9/11 commission charged that various departments' computer systems could not share information. Well, the government solved that problem, allowing Defense Department computers to reach into the foreign service's cable traffic.
    Turns out, that may not have been such a great idea, especially when this information-sharing ethos was taken one step further during the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. "We should be providing soldiers with all the intelligence and information possible," the argument went (and no one can ever say no to the Pentagon in Washington). So we have ended up with a private at an Army base in Iraq able to download secret readouts of conversations between the Secretary of Defense and the French Foreign Minister. If Private Bradley Manning had not gone to WikiLeaks, he would have found some other outlet to disseminate the data. Our anger at WikiLeaks should not obscure the fact that it is Washington's absurd data-sharing policy that made this possible. That's the scandal here that needs fixing.

    Ambassador Richard Holbrooke Died in Washington

    Remembering Ambassador Richard Holbrooke

    Click here to find out more!
    Richard Holbrooke
    Molly Riley / Reuters
    When Scott Fitzgerald heard of the death of Thomas Wolfe, he sent a message in condolence to Maxwell Perkins, their editor at Scribner's. "That great, pulsing, vital frame quiet at last," Fitzgerald wrote. "There is a great hush after him."
    To countless numbers around the world, that is how things feel with the death of Richard Holbrooke, America's diplomat extraordinary. On Dec. 10, Holbrooke was rushed to hospital in Washington with a tear in his aorta, and notwithstanding hours of surgery and constant care, died, aged 69, on the evening of Dec. 13.
    In every way, Dick Holbrooke was a big man — handsome, broad-shouldered, with a capacious mind and a generous heart. He lived a public life almost from the moment he graduated from Brown in 1962. Within months, he was in Vietnam, and soon became one of a remarkable band of young diplomats in the Saigon embassy, at one and the same time working to advance American interests in south-east Asia while learning lessons from mistakes made there — lessons they would put to use later in their careers. Dick never lost a fascination with the region, and it never lost its respect and affection for him. I remember a lunch Dick hosted for Singapore's leader Lee Kuan Yew when he was Ambassador to the U.N., and the immense pride he took in Lee's recollection of the way that Dick, when a young Assistant Secretary of State for East Asia (just 35 when he was appointed) had restored American honor in Asia in the dark years after the Vietnam war.
    Restoring honor was something of a Holbrooke skill. After four years of cowardly, shifty, and above all cruel policymaking in Washington — a miserable fiasco for which officials working for two presidents and both political parties were to blame — Holbrooke, then Assistant Secretary of State for European affairs, was tasked with finding a way to end the war in Bosnia, which had led to the deaths of some 200,00. Wheedling, bullying, negotiating, persuading, he took charge of the process that led to the Dayton Accords signed in 1995. In his drive, his boldness, his determination to do anything he could to end the killing, he demonstrated the best of American policy — actually, more than that, the best of the American character. "Try to imagine a European Holbrooke," went the frequently-asked question in 1995, as the leaders of the old continent wrung their hands in impotent pusillanimity. "You can't."
    To be sure, throughout his career there were always those who said that Dick had a high opinion of his own talents and little time for others less gifted. To which there are two answers. The first is that it ain't bragging if you can do it. Dick could do it, and how. The second is that you should go out, right now, and buy "To End a War," Holbrooke's account of the Bosnia negotiations. This superb book, a true classic of its kind, is suffused from first page to last with an extraordinary generosity for the contributions of those, well-known and obscure, who played their part in bringing Europe's worst conflict since 1945 to an end.
    That same big spirit was evident in a part of the Holbrooke resume which — I would guess — will be little noticed in most obituaries: his dynamic leadership of the Global Business Council on HIV/AIDS during the years after he left office in 2000. It was evident in the way he brought U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan and Sen. Jesse Helms, once an inveterate opponent of the U.N., during his years as Ambassador in Turtle Bay. It was evident in the days and months he labored long and often thanklessly in what I think he regarded his most difficult task of all, bringing a measure of peace, stability and security to the war-torn lands of Pakistan and Afghanistan.(Comment on this story.)
    Dick Holbrooke was a friend of mine. Just two days before he fell ill, I saw him — and his devoted wife, the writer Kati Marton — at a dinner where he proposed a toast with generosity, affection, self-deprecation, and the sort of comic timing that made you think he had missed his true profession. I liked him enormously. But for all that he did over nearly 50 years of service to his nation, and indeed to all humankind, I admired him much, much more. A great hush, indeed

    Quote of the Day

    Quotes of the Day

    An individual�s personal decision to purchase — or decline purchase — (of) health insurance from a private provider is beyond the historical reach of the U.S. Constitution.
    Monday, Dec. 13, 2010
    Open quoteAn individual's personal decision to purchase — or decline purchase — [of] health insurance from a private provider is beyond the historical reach of the U.S. Constitution.Close quote
    • HENRY HUDSON,
    • a Virginia federal judge who struck down the Obama Administration's requirement that all Americans buy health insurance


     

    Just don't know where this old man might be .......

    Great way to have Successor

    7. Warren Buffett Acquires a Successor

    JASON LEE / REUTERS
    The hiring of an investment manager isn't normally big news. But when a 39-year-old hedge fund manager gets picked to eventually replace 80-year-old legend Warren Buffett it makes international headlines. Todd Combs will leave his job at hedge fund Castle Point Capital Management in Greenwich, Conn., at the end of 2010 to join Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway. Buffett is currently the chief executive and top investment officer at his insurance and investment firm. But Berkshire is expected to split Buffett's job in two when he retires. Three years ago, Buffett said the company had a number of good choices to succeed him as CEO, but still needed to hire someone who could take over his money management role. Buffett helped set up Combs at Castle Point five years ago by finding him seed money from a private equity firm. Comb's main fund is up 34% in the past five years, well better than the Standard & Poors 500 during the same time, which has fallen more than 5%. But Buffett may have picked Combs because of what he hasn't invested in. Comb's fund specializes in financial services companies. Yet he has managed to avoid most of the long list of blow-ups of the past three years including AIG, Bear Stearns, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Lehman Brothers or Washington Mutual. 'Don't lose money' is one of Buffett's classic investment rules.

    Imran Khan and the Current economic & political situation of Pakistan

     Apparently Pakistan's economy is sliding down - two of the most hit sectors are textile and automobiles, one is struggling to export Pa...